[extropy-chat] looks like Bush will win
Giu1i0 Pri5c0
pgptag at gmail.com
Sat Oct 23 16:03:07 UTC 2004
Trend, I completely understand your frustration, and found your
explanation of why Bush will win interesting. (Unfortunately I also
think he will probably win, but lets keep finger crossed and hope for
the best, miracles can happen you know).
But I wish to warn you that remarks like this can do more harm than
good to our cause. In the same sentence you are going against
southerners (half of the US population), rural Americans (maybe more
than half), and christians (much more than half). Moreover you equate
southerners and christians with rednecks, a unPC term with negative
connotations.
Now imagine that a columnist of the religious right is reading this
(it maybe the case you know). Tomorrow he can publish an article
quoting your words out of context and with a title like "Extremist
extropian cultists insult the South, Christians, and rural Americans."
Such an article could win a couple of votes to Bush, and if things are
as tight as in 2000 these two votes could even make the difference.
I think as you do but we must all learn, also on our own lists which
perhaps are not so private as we think, to present our arguments
without insulting others.
G.
On Sat, 23 Oct 2004 16:36:58 +0100 (BST), Trend Ologist
<trendologist at yahoo.co.uk> wrote:
> Looks like Bush will win. Whatever the tally ends up
> being, must redneck Southerners be so aggressive with
> their culture? They don't like Yankee culture so they
> want to push something worse on us? Can't Southern men
> be content with their wives & mistresses and other
> 'nookie'? I swear, the next time a guy with a drawl
> approaches to attempt to convert me to Christianity
> I'll spit on the ground. I'm totally tired of so many
> Southerners trying to inflict their religion on
> America; it's not love, it's hate disguised as love.
> And they want us to pity them for 140 years ago?
> Northerners weren't particularly interested in
> abolishing slavery, they bent over backwards to avoid
> the war yet Southerners wanted the Feds to guarantee
> slavery by using Federal agents to retrieve runaway
> slaves-- plus the South wanted other completely
> un-Christian measures to be instituted.
> Sure, this is all a generalization however I can't
> avoid thinking very many Southerners want some sort of
> revenge
More information about the extropy-chat
mailing list