[extropy-chat] The Force of Human Freedom [was-isAmericafascistyet?]

[Samantha Atkins]

On Jan 30, 2005, at 10:23 AM, Greg Burch wrote:

> I don't understand your position, in which you feel justified in 
> making the bitterest criticisms of the policies advocated by others, 
> but repeatedly retreat to the statement that you have no solution to 
> offer.


Is it required that one has an alternative proposal before being able 
to offer a worthwhile critique?  If so then please explain the 
necessity.   If not then it appears that this part of your argument is 
not relevant and only serves to dismiss the critique without further 
examination.

- samantha