[extropy-chat] examples of rational irrationalism
sjatkins at mac.com
Thu Dec 7 11:18:17 UTC 2006
On Dec 6, 2006, at 6:39 AM, Lee Corbin wrote:
> The Avanguardian writes
>> Al Brooks wrote:
>>> The question is: do rational reasons exist for
>>> irrational thinking and behavior that enable one to
>>> escape irrational reality?
>> When it comes to rational irrationalism, I think these
>> guys take the cake:
> Why do you think that eliminating mankind is necessarily
Is rationality a free-floating abstraction disconnected from values,
what does the valuing and what is considered valuable? How would that
itself be "rational"?
> Don't you concur with the (generally accepted
> here) version of what it means to be rational? Namely,
> as Rafal put it, "rationality (to use the dictionary meaning)
> is optimizing behavior to achieve goals". So if your goal
> is a pristine Earth free of unnatural (i.e. human) effects,
> then what's irrational about trying to get rid of everyone,
> including yourself?
Arbitrary goals that include one's on destruction and destruction of
one's species are not themselves subject to a meta-judgement as to
their rationality? Where is the grounding for these abstractions
being tossed about?
How can it be rational to claim a naturally evolved species is
"unnatural"? How can it be rational to destroy the only thing on this
rock vaguely capable of rationality? Are we so sickened by our dizzy
More information about the extropy-chat