[extropy-chat] Humans--non-rational mode
phoenix at ugcs.caltech.edu
Thu Mar 9 18:50:25 UTC 2006
On Thu, Mar 09, 2006 at 10:28:25AM -0500, Keith Henson wrote:
> The unexplained freakin' out of the Libertarians over "Memes, MetaMemes and
> Politics" is perhaps due to these paragraphs being seen as an attack on the
I haven't heard of this.
> >The assaults on rationality that come to mind:
> >1. (the first one I ever heard of) Schelling's examples of how
> > it is sometimes very rational to be irrational (the words
> > here are very problematic, obviously)
> >2. general emotional behavior: anger, love, envy, and so forth
> > surely have evolutionary explanations, and moreover, one
> > easily sees that the *propensity* to become angry, for
> > example, in many situations pays dividends
Yes. But does jealousy make you happier, or does it serve the purposes of
Does *love* serve your purposes, or those of your genes? May that depend on
who you find yourself falling in love with?
What *are* your purposes, when it comes down to it?
> >3. the famous Damasio card experiment in which (as I understand
> > it) one cannot rationally keep track of so much data, and so
> > feelings of disfavor towards situations are necessary for
> > optimal human performance. (I dare say that such brain
> > processing can literally create a bad taste in one's mouth.)
> >4. Gladwell's book "Blink" which I have not read and do not
> > recommend, but joins the parade of claims that many situations
> > are best *not* dealt with rationally (e.g. the legend of "The
> > Marines vs. the Wall-Street brokers)
5. The Wason card test, where even people trained in logic have trouble
giving the right answer to a pretty simple abstract problem, while an
isomorphic problem in the language of social cheating (detecting underage
drinkers) is easy for everyone to solve.
6. "X and Y add up to $110, Y costs $100 more than X. How much is X?"
Reportedly the fast answer even for trained people is "$10", but this effect
fades if the total is $233 insstead of $110, say. This may not seem to
serious, but I think it may say something about how fast responses (habit,
pattern completion) can sideline reasoning.
-xx- Damien X-)
More information about the extropy-chat