[ExI] agency-based personal identity defined
Thomas
thomas at thomasoliver.net
Sun Jun 24 19:47:32 UTC 2007
> Jef Allbright wrote:
>
> Damn. Now I feel compelled to rebut this claim [...]
>
> Agency-based personal identity naturally accommodates our present
> everyday view of a constant relationship between the agent and the
> abstract entity which it represents. Even though both of these change
> with time, the relationship -- the personal identity -- is constant.
> Agency-based personal identity is more extensible because it
> accommodates the idea of duplicate persons with no paradox and no
> hanging question of what constitutes sufficient physical/functional
> similarity. And agency-based personal identity accommodates future
> scenarios of variously enabled/limited variants of oneself performing
> tasks on behalf of a common entity and viewed as precisely *that*
> entity for social/moral/judicial purposes by itself (itselves) and
> others. Perhaps counter-intuitively, agency-based personal identity
> shows us that agents more specifically differentiated in their
> function will maintain the entity-agent relationship more reliably due
> to less potential for conflict based on similar values expressed
> within disparate contexts.
>
> - Jef
Earlier you mentioned my audience as your motive for belaboring this
discussion. In the interest of reducing compulsion I'd like you to
know that I consider your above explanation competent and
sufficient. You have succeeded in expanding the scope of my
understanding of personal identity. I hereby formally excuse you
from feeling any explicit or implied obligation to perform this
exercise on my behalf. I very much appreciate your concern and I
feel sure this appreciation will grow as I apply this concept in the
future. In addition I gained insight into the frustrating process of
attempting to argue from an expanded context. The paragraph above
indicates that you've gotten better at it. -- Thomas
Thomas at ThomasOliver.net
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.extropy.org/pipermail/extropy-chat/attachments/20070624/d82c731d/attachment.html>
More information about the extropy-chat
mailing list