[ExI] Minds, Personalities, and Love
thomas at thomasoliver.net
Thu Jun 28 06:51:47 UTC 2007
Jef Allbright wrote:
> [...] "[human agency] is subtly distinct from the
> concept of free will, the philosophical doctrine that our choices are
> not the product of causal chains, but are significantly free or
> undetermined. Human agency entails the uncontroversial, weaker claim
> that humans do in fact make decisions and enact them on the world."
> [For Thomas, the above statement indicates why thinking in terms of
> agency is more coherent and extensible than thinking in terms of will.
> Will is more of a special case.]
Yes, I agree with the rider that will, defined as "the faculty of
conscious and especially of deliberate action" cannot be excluded
from qualifying personhood. Free-from-determinism-will makes no sense.
> [...] Consciousness (and Will) goes along for the ride,
> not because it's essential, but because it's value-added.
Not essential for life or observable identity, but personality?
Without capacity for consciousness you lose your personhood.
Someone else might see you as a person, but they have a sad
misunderstanding of the facts. -- Thomas
Thomas at ThomasOliver.net
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
More information about the extropy-chat