[ExI] What is meant here by "fascism"?
Lee Corbin
lcorbin at rawbw.com
Sat Oct 6 21:24:44 UTC 2007
Several people, notably Natasha and PJ Manney, are using
the term in a way that I don't understand. The latter, in fact,
wrote on September 27
"But remember this: even fascists believe they're doing the right
thing. They balance what they and the country gain by their actions
against what they and the country might lose if they refrained.
Hence, their behavior."
I would like to know who or what is being described. Yes I do
understand that the main target of these remarks, perhaps quite
justifiably but perhaps not, is the Bush administration. But what
exactly is the meaning of "fascism" here?
(No doubt the above was not meant to be defining. If "fascist"
were to mean that the *only* considerations the leaders of a
country make are whether or not actions benefit/harm their
nation, then no country in modern history is fascist, because
there are *always* other considerations, e.g., pilfering. But
I do understand that the above may be a step towards such
a definition.)
The answers to even a few of the following "yes and no" type
questions will help a lot.
1. Is Russia at the present time a fascist country?
2. Are there countries of Western Europe that are fascist
at the present time?
3. Is Mexico or Cuba fascist at the present time? I ask because
both the Federalis and Castro's henchmen appear to violate
people's liberties almost at will.
4. If two countries have identical profiles of freedom and economic
structure, but one is an ally of the United States and one is an
enemy, is the former thereby more fascist?
5. Can a country be a little bit fascist? That is, if there has been
a single incident of government action that has resulted in a
clearly unjustifiable loss of liberty (e.g. Norway), is the country
thereby fascist? Or is it a matter of degree?
6. Do the civil liberties of a substantial number of people actually
have to be infringed, or is it enough that the laws (or known
potential) provide the possibility for such?
7. During what decade did the United States become fascist? Was
the U.S. fascist during the McCarthy years? What about during
the sixties when the FBI spyed on prominent members of the
Civil Rights movement?
8. What other terms of approbation are used which are not employed
by anyone to self-describe them? That is, I consider it a great blow
against any political term if no one can be found who embraces that
term. If everyone says, "I'm not a fascist", then the meaning of the
term is made much, much more difficult. Why use a term that no
one employs self-descriptively?
Thanks,
Lee
More information about the extropy-chat
mailing list