[ExI] Private and government R&D
dan_ust at yahoo.com
Thu Jul 2 15:33:27 UTC 2009
--- On Thu, 7/2/09, Eschatoon Magic <eschatoon at gmail.com> wrote:
> On Wed, Jul 1, 2009 at 8:28 PM, Dan<dan_ust at yahoo.com>
> > --- On Wed, 7/1/09, Eschatoon Magic <eschatoon at gmail.com>
>>> Instead of making a religion war of
>>> this, how about simply
>>> acknowledging that both private and public R&D
>>> have their roles?
>> While that sounds like the wise course, the point
>> under debate was whether one is better at delivering the
>> goods as well as whether each has certain path dependencies.
>> (I didn't use the term "path dependencies," but this was
>> what I meant by pointing out that a voluntary system would
>> likely have R&D funding, but not in exactly the same way
>> as the current coercive system.)
>> There is also the problem that under the coercive
>> system, some people are forced to pay for others' pet
>> projects. Some might find no problem with this, but I
>> think that's relevant to the discussion because coercion
>> introduces certain features that wouldn't be found under a
>> voluntary system.
> What are "the goods"? To whom, when,
> how, and at what price, they are
> "delivered"? And first of all, what is "better"? I think
> wine is
> better than beer, you may think beer is better than wine.
> There is one
> sane solution: I drink wine and you drink beer.
Yes, and that's the voluntary solution, no? The coercive solution would be for you or I (or some third party) to come in and tell us what to drink regardless of our individual preferences.
> There are many types of cohercive systems. I can force you
> to do what I say by pointing a gun, or by withdrawing a loan.
To me, that's reasoning that would justify rape by saying she was forcing me to rape her because she withheld sex. To wit, there's a big difference between someone not funding your pet project -- presuming it's her or his money we're talking about and it doesn't violate any voluntarily arrived at agreements or contracts -- and someone stopping you by threatening you with a gun. Notably, with the not funding, you can always seek other sources of funding.
Do You Yahoo!?
Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around
More information about the extropy-chat