[ExI] biology term

spike spike66 at att.net
Wed Oct 12 04:10:41 UTC 2016



With the topic of Lee Corbin coming up, I am reminded of the last discussion
we had, which has been nearly a year ago.  I may bring up topics for the
next couple of months or more as I think of them: things he and I discussed
when together.

I don't know the terminology in genetics which is why I can't look up the
answers, but I think we have some biology hipsters here.

When a mutation is recessive and each parent carries one copy, there is
about a 25% chance the offspring will inherit both copies of the mutation.
In the case of a lot of genetic diseases, if either copy is the
non-mutation, then the disease is not expressed.  So if two carriers of that
mutation mate, then the offspring have about a 50% chance of being a carrier
and about a 25% chance of being free entirely of the mutation.

In the case of Tay-Sachs disease, it is known that some populations (such as
Ashkenazi) have a number of carriers, so the Jewish couples have a known
risk of suffering the heartbreak of a Tay-Sachs baby, who will not survive
to bring them grandchildren.  

Given that a mutation is detrimental in some cases, why does that mutation
survive in a population?  A theory that Lee Corbin and I kicked around is
that in every case where a mutation carries the risk of causing infant death
in a homozygote, there should be some health benefit somehow to the
heterozygote carriers.  In the case of Tay-Sachs, that benefit is an
increased resistance to tuberculosis.  Another example is sickle-cell anemia
gives the heterozygote carriers increased resistance to malaria.

Biology hipsters, what is that phenomenon called?  If I don't know the name
of something I could waste hours Googleing around and finding nada.  Lee
didn't know the term either.  That kind of disease, expressed only in
offspring of two carriers, should have a name.  There might be a name to the
theory that all such maladies must have some corresponding benefit,
otherwise the mutation would gradually disappear due to reduced viability of
the offspring.

spike




More information about the extropy-chat mailing list