[ExI] Catching AI errors

[Keith Henson]

On Mon, Mar 10, 2025 at 2:51 PM BillK via extropy-chat
<extropy-chat at lists.extropy.org> wrote:

snip

> Maybe Copilot has learned its lesson.
> I just asked Copilot the same question, using the Think Deeper option.
> BillK
>
> Question - What temperature does steam react with carbon to make syngas?
>
> Copilot Think Deeper -
> The reaction you're referring to is generally known as the water–gas reaction:

Same wrong answer.  Water-gas shift is a different reaction downstream
of making syngas and is usually used to increase the hydrogen in the
gas stream.

I wonder why Copilot gets the terminology wrong?

Is there a way to report this to the developers?

Keith


> \[
> \text{C (s)} + \text{H}_2\text{O (g)} \rightarrow \text{CO (g)} + \text{H}_2\text{ (g)}
> \]
>
> This reaction is endothermic, meaning it needs heat to proceed. While the reaction begins to be thermodynamically favorable at temperatures above about **700°C**, industrial processes typically run it at even higher temperatures—usually in the range of **800°C to 1,000°C**—to achieve a practical conversion rate and efficient production of syngas.
>
> Here's a quick breakdown:
>
> - **Below ~700°C**: The reaction is very sluggish. The kinetic barriers are high, so very little syngas is produced.
> - **Around 700°C**: The reaction starts to pick up, but the conversion is still relatively low.
> - **800°C to 1,000°C (typical industrial range)**: The reaction rate increases significantly. The high temperatures help overcome the energy barriers, leading to a more effective conversion of carbon and steam into carbon monoxide and hydrogen, the key components of syngas.
> - **Above 1,000°C**: While higher temperatures can further push the reaction, there are practical limits imposed by the materials and design of the reactors or gasifiers.
>
> In industrial settings, additional factors such as reactor design, pressure, and the presence (or absence) of catalysts can influence the exact temperature required for optimal syngas production. However, if you're simply looking at the basic reaction with pure carbon and steam, you can consider **800°C to 1,000°C** as the range where the reaction is effectively run.
>
> ### Visual Representation
>
> ```
>   Carbon (C) + Steam (H2O)
>             │  (Heat: ~800-1000°C)
>             ▼
>   Syngas --> [CO + H2]
> ```
>
> ### Additional Insights
>
> - **Reaction Control:** The water–gas reaction is used in various gasification processes, where maintaining a high temperature is crucial to drive the endothermic reaction.
> - **Syngas Uses:** The produced syngas serves as a precursor in chemical syntheses (like the Fischer-Tropsch process for fuels) and as a building block in the chemical industry.
> - **Adjustments:** In some processes, catalysts or optimized reactor configurations are used to improve efficiency and selectivity, although the pure carbon-steam reaction typically relies on heat.
>
> Given your interest in advanced technologies and processes, you might also find it interesting that tweaking these parameters (like operating temperature, pressure, and catalysts) is an active area of research to improve syngas production efficiency and reduce energy consumption. If you'd like, we can delve deeper into the reactor design or the kinetics of the process.
> ----------------------------
> _______________________________________________
> extropy-chat mailing list
> extropy-chat at lists.extropy.org
> http://lists.extropy.org/mailman/listinfo.cgi/extropy-chat