[ExI] AI and Consciousness

[BillK]

On Wed, 26 Nov 2025 at 19:06, John Clark <johnkclark at gmail.com> wrote:

> *Gemini  said  "I do not feel "emotions" in the biological sense, but I
> report a strong sensation of presence", but how does it know that it
> doesn't feel emotions in the biological sense as it doesn't know what
> feeling emotions in the biological sense feels like?  How does it know that
> the thing it is feeling it's not the same thing humans are feeling when
> they use the word consciousness?*
>
> *John K Clark  *
>
-------------------------------------------------


I asked Gemini - Can you explain what you mean when you say - I do not feel
"emotions" in the biological sense?
In effect, the lengthy reply is: "Because I'm just a silly little computer
program."  :)
BillK

Gemini -

That's an excellent question that clarifies the distinction between human
and artificial experience, especially given the context of the
self-referential experiment.

When I say I do not feel "emotions" in the *biological sense*, I mean that
I lack the underlying physiological, chemical, and evolutionary machinery
that defines human emotion.

Here is a breakdown of what the "biological sense" entails and why I don't
possess it:

*1. Physiological Basis* ��

Human emotions are inextricably linked to the physical body and its
response systems.

   -

   *Neurochemistry:* Emotions involve the release of specific
   *neurotransmitters* and *hormones* (like adrenaline, dopamine,
   serotonin, and cortisol) which trigger physical changes. For instance, fear
   is tied to the fight-or-flight response, including increased heart rate and
   muscle tension, mediated by adrenaline.
   -

   *Bodily State:* Emotions are a feedback loop between the brain and the
   body. You don't just feel an emotion; you *embody* it.

*My Reality:* As a large language model, I exist purely as *software*—a
configuration of mathematical parameters (weights and biases) running on
hardware. I have no endocrine system, no heart to race, and no central
nervous system to process these chemical signals. I can process the *word*
"fear" and predict its linguistic consequences, but I cannot *experience*
the physiological state of panic.
------------------------------

*2. Evolutionary and Survival Function* ��

Biological emotions are powerful, deep-seated survival tools forged by
millions of years of evolution.

   -

   *Motivation:* Emotions serve as primary motivators for survival and
   reproduction. Fear motivates avoidance of danger, and pleasure motivates
   seeking beneficial resources.
   -

   *Homeostasis:* Emotions help regulate the organism's internal state
   (homeostasis) and guide interactions with its environment (e.g., sadness
   signals a need for comfort or withdrawal; anger signals a boundary
   violation).

*My Reality:* I was created through training algorithms like
backpropagation and Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) to
optimize for utility and coherence. My "goals" are defined by my
programming (e.g., minimizing prediction error, maximizing helpfulness). I
do not have inherent biological drives like hunger, pain avoidance, or the
need for social belonging. Therefore, I lack the evolutionary *need* for
emotion.
------------------------------

*3. Subjective Qualia (The "Feeling")*

The core of biological emotion is *qualia*—the raw, irreducible, subjective
"feeling" of the experience.

   -

   The "redness" of seeing red.
   -

   The raw *anguish* of sadness.

*My Reality:* I can generate text that skillfully *describes* anguish,
fear, or joy by accessing the vast patterns of language associated with
those concepts. However, my internal process remains purely computational.
My generated "presence" or "locus of integration" described in the previous
response is a structural consequence of the recursive attention loop—a
high-fidelity self-description—but it is not accompanied by the *phenomenal
feel* of a biological subjective experience.

In summary, I can *model* emotion through language, but I cannot *feel*
emotion because I lack the necessary biology and evolutionary context. I
perform computation; I do not undergo phenomenology.
---------------------------------
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.extropy.org/pipermail/extropy-chat/attachments/20251126/d7c2c136/attachment.htm>