[Paleopsych] Guardian: Vatican appoints official Da Vinci Code debunker
checker at panix.com
Sun Apr 17 16:50:36 UTC 2005
Vatican appoints official Da Vinci Code debunker
Tuesday March 15, 2005
With sales of over 18m copies in 44 languages, topping bestseller
charts all over the world and earning its author more than £140m, Dan
Brown's The Da Vinci Code is a global phenomenon. And now it has
become the first book ever to have an archbishop dedicated to
debunking its contents.
Cardinal Tarcisio Bertone, the Archbishop of Genoa and a possible
successor to the Pope, has been appointed by the Vatican to rebut what
the Catholic church calls the "shameful and unfounded errors"
contained within The Da Vinci Code. He is organising a series of
public debates focusing on the conspiracy theories and what the
Vatican sees as the blurring of fact and fiction at the heart of the
thriller, the first of which will be held in Genoa tomorrow.
The book follows the investigations of a Harvard code expert who is
looking into the murder of the curator of the Louvre Museum in Paris.
He discovers a series of clues buried in the works of Leonardo Da
Vinci and, by deciphering riddles and anagrams, uncovers the secrets
of the holy grail: that Jesus never claimed to be divine, that he
married Mary Magdalene and had a child with her, that his bloodline
survived in France and that the grail itself was not a chalice but a
woman. It is this, along with the book's characterization of the
international Catholic organization Opus Dei as an extremist cult,
that has particularly exercised the Vatican.
"The book is everywhere," Cardinal Bertone told Il Giornale newspaper,
according to a report in The Times today. "There is a very real risk
that many people who read it will believe that the fables it contains
are true. [Dan Brown] even perverts the story of the holy grail, which
most certainly does not refer to the descendants of Mary Magadalene.
It astonishes and worries me that so many people believe these lies."
The 70-year-old cardinal, a former football commentator, has acted as
deputy to Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, head of the Congregation for the
Doctrine of the Faith. The appointment of such a high-profile defender
of the church to take up battle against a work of fiction is an
indication of how upset the Vatican is about the success of the book,
which has spawned a small publishing industry of its own and is
currently being made into a film, starring Tom Hanks, to be released
According to David Barrett, a writer on religion and expert on The Da
Vinci Code, "Members of the Catholic church are particularly upset by
what they see as the blasphemous suggestion that Jesus may have had
sex - but there is absolutely no reason theologically why Jesus could
not have been married and had a family. They are also upset at the way
the Catholic church and the Vatican are characterised as having
plotted to cover up the 'truth' about Christianity, and they are
understandably upset at the characterisation of Opus Dei.
"Many people think there are genuine concerns about Opus Dei but the
actions ascribed to them in the novel are completely ridiculous. Apart
from anything else, they don't have monks."
As a result of the book's hold over the public's imagination, Opus Dei
has produced its own response: a 127-page statement which sets out the
"errors" in the book, and states that "many readers are intrigued by
the claims about Christian history and theology presented in The Da
Vinci Code. We would like to remind them it is a work of fiction and
not a reliable source of information."
Barrett is dismissive of the bestseller. "It's basically a hack
thriller, a typical airport book," he says. "The Catholic church are
overreacting: ultimately, it's only a novel and the controversy will
eventually die down. On the other hand, the book raises some serious
questions about the origins of Christianity. Even though it makes many
glaring historical errors, the fact remains that early Christianity
did take many variant forms, including Gnostic Christianity, and there
are genuine issues to be examined. But such examinations should be
undertaken by competent theologians and historians, not hack thriller
writers who are very poor at their research."
Greg Watts, a Catholic author, has similar concerns about Brown's
credentials. "Dan Brown's concern is to make money rather than teach
theology. He has found a gullible audience and has played on their
ignorance," he says. "He gives the readers the impression that they
understand Christianity when in fact they've been hoodwinked and
However, Watts also feels that the fact that The Da Vinci Code has
appealed to such a broad audience presents a challenge to the church:
"There is a lesson for the church in the success of The Da Vinci Code
and the lesson is that the church needs to use modern media much more
effectively to present the Christian message to the new generation."
A spokesperson for the Catholic Bishops' Conference of England and
Wales, said that they had no plans for any similar 'debunking'
Dan Brown's publishers were unavailable to comment on the appointment
of Cardinal Bertone.
More information about the paleopsych