[Paleopsych] ABC News: Proving Einstein Right

Premise Checker checker at panix.com
Fri Jan 28 16:13:51 UTC 2005

Proving Einstein Right

Most of the Great Physicist's Ideas Have Been Confirmed, But Not All

    Jan. 24, 2005 - It was 100 years ago when an obscure 26-year-old
    office worker in a Swiss patent office submitted five papers that
    would radically change the way people think about the universe.

    In fact, Albert Einstein's ideas, devised entirely from thought, were
    so advanced that scientists are still trying to prove some of them.

    To find evidence for the brilliant physicist's ideas, researchers are
    using the latest in technology and a century of research -- neither of
    which Einstein had when he devised such profound concepts as the
    General Theory of Relativity.

    "It's amazing Einstein came up with his theories just by thinking
    about the situation," said Peter Shawhan, a staff scientist at the
    California Institute of Technology.

Catching a Wave

    Shawhan is part of a large team of researchers who operate LIGO, a set
    of two giant, L-shaped experiments in Louisiana marshland and
    Washington state forestland. The facilities each feature two
    2.5-mile-long steel tubes built in perfectly straight lines that are
    designed to detect one of the faintest and most rare signals in the
    universe -- gravitational waves.

    According to Einstein's General Theory of Relativity, gravitational
    waves are sent out by any object that undergoes acceleration. The
    waves are so faint, however, that only those emanating from huge
    events -- such as colliding neutron stars or two black holes smashing
    together -- can be detected.

    Even waves from these events are so faint that by the time they reach
    Earth, they will be recorded by a difference of timing in the
    instruments amounting to just 0.0000000000000000000000001th of a

    "This is one of the hardest parts of his theory to prove because the
    waves we hope to see are just so incredibly weak," said Shawhan. "It's
    a tiny effect."

    So far, the crew of scientists has no direct evidence the waves are
    there. But a century ago Einstein proposed their existence, and so
    they're confident they'll prove him right. It's just a matter of when.

    An instrument at the joint of the two passageways sends light beams
    down each arm. The light travels down the tubes and hits mirrors at
    the near and far ends of each tunnel and then bounces back and forth
    100 times.

    If no gravitational wave has been detected, then both light beams
    arrive back at the source at exactly the same time. But if a
    gravitational wave has struck Earth, then it will ever so slightly
    alter the path of the beams so one will arrive fractions of a second
    before the other.

    The problem is, to measure something so slight, every aspect of the
    experiment has to be extremely precise. And although LIGO is extremely
    precise, it isn't as precise as it could be, says Shawhan.

    "If there is a storm, it shakes the ground. High winds can shake the
    buildings, which affect the readings, as does general traffic in the
    area," he said.

A Waiting Game

    To buffer the skewing affect of local vibrations, engineers are in the
    process of installing a feedback control system that will eliminate
    such outside "noise." They're also fine-tuning the instruments'
    mirrors to prevent warping by heat from the lasers.

    By 2013, LIGO is due to be ramped up even further so it can detect
    gravitational waves emanating from even further out in space. That
    should improve the experiment's chances since researchers suspect that
    events large enough to emit a gravitational wave big enough to detect
    are few and far between.

    "We'll be able to detect events 10 times farther away with the
    improvements," said Shawhan. "By then, there's a good chance we'll see
    something. Otherwise, we might have to wait 10 to 100 years for a big

    Three other similar facilities in Italy, Japan and Germany are also
    waiting for a big wave. With so much money, work and time invested,
    some may wonder if all the effort might be in vain. But they're not
    just banking on Einstein's brilliance.

    In 1993, two Princeton University scientists won a Nobel Prize for
    demonstrating that the increasing speed of two spiraling neutron stars
    fits exactly with Einstein's theory of relativity and gravitational

    "They've been tracking this for some 20 years and the change in orbit
    agrees exactly with the general theory of relativity," said Shawhan.
    "It looks like great confirmation, but it's not a direct one."

What Did Einstein Miss?

    While the LIGO team is eager to find direct confirmation of
    gravitational waves and prove Einstein right, other groups are
    scanning space for evidence that the physicist's theory might be
    slightly off.

    Why search for chinks in Einstein's armor? As his theory now stands,
    the ideas don't mesh completely with another major field of physics --
    quantum theory. Quantum theory examines all matter and motion in terms
    of particles. As the theories now stand, Einstein's General Theory of
    Relativity doesn't incorporate all the concepts within quantum theory.
    So scientists have yet to discover a "Theory of Everything" --
    something Einstein spent the last 30 years of his life pursuing -- in

    "Einstein's theory of gravity is not a complete theory," said Michael
    Salamon, a physicist at NASA headquarters in Washington, D.C. "In
    order to probe gravity fully, we believe there are deviations from
    Einstein's classical theory. Our mission is designed to find those

    Salamon is part of NASA's Gravity Probe B mission, which has launched
    four gyroscopes into orbit around Earth. The sensitive instruments
    were designed to detect whether or not a large spinning object in
    space (in this case, Earth) drags space-time -- the fabric of space --
    with it, as Einstein's theory predicts.

    "It's like twirling a spoon in a jar of honey," explains Salamon. "You
    see the honey dragging along with the spoon. It's analogous to what
    happens in space."

    Scientists with the Gravity Probe B mission announced last fall that
    the instruments have indeed proven that space-time is dragged by large
    spinning objects, as Einstein predicted. But as more data streams in,
    they hope to also reveal aspects of gravity that Einstein didn't
    predict. It's this information that could point to an all-encompassing
    theory that includes both Einstein's thinking and the more recent
    concepts of quantum theory.

    Even if scientists find evidence for new explanations of the universe,
    Salamon stresses that Einstein's theories will still play a central

    "Whatever new theory we come up with," he said, "it will ultimately
    contain Einstein's original thinking. There is no doubt about that."

More information about the paleopsych mailing list