[Paleopsych] NYT: Seeing Creation and Evolution in Grand Canyon
checker at panix.com
Sun Oct 9 01:01:20 UTC 2005
Seeing Creation and Evolution in Grand Canyon
[This is a great article. Click the URL to get some excellent graphics.]
By JODI WILGOREN
GRAND CANYON NATIONAL PARK, Ariz. - Tom Vail, who has been leading
rafting trips down the Colorado River here for 23 years, corralled his
charges under a rocky outcrop at Carbon Creek and pointed out the
remarkable 90-degree folds in the cliff overhead.
Geologists date this sandstone to 550 million years ago and explain
the folding as a result of pressure from shifting faults underneath.
But to Mr. Vail, the folds suggest the Grand Canyon was carved 4,500
years ago by the great global flood described in Genesis as God's
punishment for humanity's sin.
"You see any cracks in that?" he asked. "Instead of bending like that,
it should have cracked." The material "had to be soft" to bend, Mr.
Vail said, imagining its formation in the flood. When somebody
suggested that pressure over time could create plasticity in the
rocks, Mr. Vail said, "That's just a theory."
"It's all theory, right?" asked Jack Aiken, 63, an Assemblies of God
minister in Alaska who has a master's degree in geology. "Except
what's in the Good Book."
For Mr. Vail and 29 guests on his Canyon Ministries trip, this was
vacation as religious pilgrimage, an expedition in search of evidence
that God created the earth in six days 6,000 years ago, just as
That same week, a few miles upriver, a decidedly different group of 24
rafters surveyed the same rock formations - but through the lens of
science rather than what Mr. Vail calls "biblical glasses." Sponsored
by the National Center for Science Education, the chief challenger to
creationists' influence in public schools, this trip was a floating
geology seminar, charting the canyon's evolution through eons of
"Look at the weathering, look at the size of the pieces," Eugenie C.
Scott, the center director, said of markings in Black Tail Canyon. "To
a standard geologist, to somebody who actually studies geology, this
just shouts out at you: This is really old; this is really gradual."
Two groups examining the same evidence. Traveling nearly identical
itineraries, snoozing under the same stars and bathing in the same
chocolate-colored river. Yet, standing at opposite ends of the growing
creation-evolution debate, they seemed to speak in different tongues.
Science unequivocally dates the earth's age at 4.5 billion years, and
the canyon's layers at some two billion years. Even the intelligent
design movement, which argues that evolution alone cannot explain
life's complexity, does not challenge the long history of the earth.
But a core of creationists like Mr. Vail continue to champion a
Bible-based theory of the canyon's carving. And polls show many
Americans are unconvinced by scientific knowledge.
Though it did not ask specifically about the global flood or six-day
creation, a November 2004 Gallup survey found that a third of the
public believes the Bible is the actual word of God that should be
taken literally and that 45 percent think God created human beings
"pretty much in their present form" within the last 10,000 years.
Gallup found in another poll that 5 percent of scientists, and fewer
than 1 percent of earth and life scientists, adopted the "Young Earth"
The twin rafting trips epitomize the parallel universes often
inhabited by Americans with polarized positions. Members of both
groups said they had signed up for these charters to be surrounded by
like-minded people. Indeed, all the American adults on Mr. Vail's
boats voted for President Bush last fall, while all but two on the
evolutionists' rafts cast ballots for Senator John Kerry.
When not running the rapids, Mr. Vail's group, which included three
pastors, sat in makeshift sanctuaries of sand and stone to offer
psalms and prayers of praise for their surroundings.
Some were committed creationists and others were still asking
questions. But all began with a literal interpretation of the Bible,
seeking examples in the rocks to support its story that God did it all
in less than a week.
When they made camp, Dr. Scott's rafters, nearly half with Ph.D.'s in
science, had evening discussions of tidal patterns and plateau shifts,
as well as tutorials on tactics in the evolution debate. Most of them
ardently secular, a few practicing believers, they started with what
they see as unchallengeable facts about the Earth's age, and dismissed
creationism as unscientific. After each "geology moment," Dr. Scott
play-acted the creationists, saying sarcastically of their evidence,
"My part of the lesson is always a lot shorter and less detailed."
Mr. Vail, whose book on the Grand Canyon scientists tried to ban from
park stores last year, describes this natural wonder as "Exhibit A"
for Young Earth creationists. Dr. Scott calls it a scientists' Louvre.
To Kathryn Crotts, 56, a pastor's wife from Greensboro, N.C. ,
touching the canyon's basement rock was a spiritual moment.
"In the book of Genesis, it talks about God walking the face of the
earth," Mrs. Crotts explained. "Maybe His footprints are there."
But to Charlie Webb, 58, an emergency-room doctor in Colorado Springs,
it is evolution that answers "the great philosophical questions why
are we here, where did we come from."
"Evolution is the basis of biology, biology is the basis of medicine,"
said Dr. Webb, dismissing the flood explanation as childish and
pathetic. "You're messing with something important when you mess with
For eight days and 280 miles, with a reporter along for half of each
journey, the groups relaxed on motorized rafts, hiked the hills, dined
on Dutch-oven delicacies, frolicked in waterfalls and admired
rainbows, each awed by what they see as truth.
Origins of Two Journeys
About 4.5 million people visit the Grand Canyon each year, peering
over the rim and perhaps popping into a gift shop, where Mr. Vail's
book, "The Grand Canyon: A Different View," ranked 17th among 800
products sold last year. Some 22,000 hardy souls raft its river.
Mr. Vail, 57, a former corporate computer manager, took his first trip
in 1980, and soon "turned in my three-piece suit for a pair of
flip-flops." He had been guiding full time a dozen years when a pilot
celebrating her 40th birthday rode on his raft and whispered the
Gospel in his ear.
That fall, in a tent in the Himalayas, he recited the Sinner's Prayer
in the Bible she had sent with him, and, he said, "I came home a child
Back on the river, Mr. Vail said, "I started asking, 'How does what I
see here in the canyon relate to what I read in God's word?' " He
attended creationist seminars, married the airline pilot, and in 1997
founded Canyon Ministries, which brings some 200 Christians to the
river each year.
His 2003 book, a coffee-table-quality photo gallery with quotations
from Scripture, has sold 40,000 copies, despite science organizations'
protests of its sale in park shops.
Dr. Scott, 59, first chartered a canyon expedition in 1999. A former
professor of physical anthropology, she has run the National Center
for Science Education, a 3,800-member advocacy group based in Oakland,
Calif., for 17 years.
Among the rafters on this year's trip were Susan Epperson, 64, a
former high school biology teacher who was the plaintiff in the 1967
Supreme Court case that found Arkansas' law banning the teaching of
evolution unconstitutional, and Ken Saladin, 56, a professor at
Georgia College and State University in Milledgeville who has been
protesting any mix of church and state for 30 years.
"I won't defend evolution," Dr. Scott said in exasperation one
evening. "We don't defend the spherical Earth. We need to stop
defending, as they put it, Darwinism, and just make them show they
have a scientific view."
At orientation, when the rafters wrote their names on mugs, Libbi
Hendley, 52, who owns a newsstand in Boone, N.C., with her husband,
marked hers with the Christian fish symbol. In the other group, Eric
Hildeman, 34, a Milwaukee seminarian turned atheist accountant, wore a
cap with the same symbol, filled with the word "Darwin."
Worship in a Glorious Cathedral
"Isn't this a wonderful cathedral to meet in?" the Rev. Stephen
Crotts, a pastor in Greensboro, N.C., asked the congregation
encircling him on a Sunday morning.
The worshipers sat on the ground, many of them barefoot. The rushing
river and canyon wrens accompanied the impromptu choir along with Mr.
Vail's wife, Paula, on flute and 17-year-old Andrew Panes, who brought
a guitar from England. The preacher had three days' growth.
"What is this place that God created saying to you and me?" asked Mr.
Crotts, 55. "One of the things it says to me is I'm small and God and
the world He created is huge. This is a man-dwarfing place."
Religion permeated Mr. Vail's trip, the group bowing heads before
meals and hikes. At lunch one day, four women clustered in a tight
hug, praying for one who had multiple sclerosis.
"We just need to talk to the only person who can do anything about
it," said Linda Lomax, 58.
When Lucy Panes, 20, shouted, "Oh my God!" after a guide doused her
with river water, she immediately covered her mouth, only to be
admonished by her mother, Diana, "Please don't shout that."
Diana Panes began questioning evolution, which she had studied in
school like most everyone else, seven years ago when Andrew came home
from school asking whether Genesis was fable or history, and about
dinosaurs dating back millions of years.
"I was gobsmacked," Mrs. Panes recalled.
So she started reading, attending lectures, watching creationist
videos. "I don't want to believe in fairy tales. I'm interested in
truth," Mrs. Panes said.
Convinced that Jesus himself believed the global flood and genealogy
of Genesis were true historical accounts, "the whole thing becomes his
reputation at stake," Mrs. Panes, 54, said of why she felt compelled
to come to the canyon to see for herself. "For years there were huge
areas I couldn't answer. My faith was devotional."
Of the explanations offered by Mr. Vail and other creationists, she
said, "For me it was just the most immense relief that it didn't have
to remain a mystery forever."
Questions and More Questions
But Brenda Melvin, 46, a nurse practitioner, was not so sure. "My
Christian heart wanted to believe, but my scientific mind had
questions," Ms. Melvin said. "I believe totally that God created
heaven and Earth - I don't know how he did it, I don't know exactly
when he did it. I don't know that we're ever going to learn the
Her pastor, Paul Phillips, also did not accept Mr. Vail's explanations
of rock layers and fossil remnants without question. "Whatever he
says, I'm just trying to think: There's a really smart person, there's
tons of really smart people, that think the other side," he said.
For Mr. Phillips, 42, the most profound revelation came not about when
the canyon was carved, but why: Genesis recounts the great flood as
God's harsh judgment on a world filled with sin.
"If I'm a sinner, and this is the punishment for sin, then I might
want to rethink my position before God," he said. "If you acknowledge
a creator and a designer, then you have to deal with that entity. If
it just happened, then I don't have to worry about an entity that
ripped apart the earth."
Faith in Science
"I've always believed in evolution," Irene Rosenthal, 71, a
semiretired psychologist, said over soup one night.
"Accepted evolution," interjected George H. Griffin, 58, a retired law
enforcement officer in Colorado. "That's what Genie wants us to say,"
he said, referring to Dr. Scott. "Genie said anyone who said
'believed' would have to walk home."
Dr. Scott and others cringe at creationists' charge that Darwin's
theories have become dogmatic faith, that creationism and evolution
are just two parallel belief systems, equally plausible and
unprovable. "We have faith in science, but it's not a religion," said
Herb Masters, a retired firefighter. "It's a faith in a body of
While the creationists sang hymns, Dr. Scott taught her crew a
biologist's ditty about the amphioxus, a fishlike invertebrate in the
human evolutionary line, to the tune of "It's a Long Way From
It's a long way from amphioxus - it's a long way to us.
It's a long way from amphioxus to the meanest human cuss.
Goodbye fins and gill slits,
Hello lungs and hair!
It's a long, long way from amphioxus,
But we come from there.
Most on the science trip were atheists or agnostics, dismissive and at
times disrespectful of religion. Standing under a gushing waterfall,
they joked about baptism. When a white dove appeared after a harrowing
hike, Dr. Scott teased, "It's a sign!"
But six of the rafters said they belonged to churches or synagogues,
four attending weekly. Alan Gishlick, with silver-painted toenails
sticking out of his Tevas and a shoulder tattoo of a Buddhist word
puzzle meaning "Knowledge makes me content," said he was a "devout
"Ultimately, creationism is not just bad science to me, it's bad
Christianity, it's Bible worship," said Mr. Gishlick, 32, a
paleontology Ph.D. "There's just no reason to look at these patterns
of layered sediment, or in the fossil record, or at the stars, and
think that what you're seeing isn't what you're seeing. God doesn't
require you to be stupid, to deny what you see, to deny what you
Ms. Epperson, who sings in the choir at her Presbyterian church and
brought her Bible along on the trip, said, "The more you learn about
science, the more magnificent God is.
"I can look at a rainbow, and I know that white light can hit water
droplets and it gets dispersed and the light spreads out and has lots
of different colors," she said, "and I also say, 'Thank you, God, for
the rainbow.' "
She said she asked God whether her role as an evolution advocate was
meant to be her mission. "I say, 'God, if this is wrong, if I'm wrong,
please strike me with lightning, because I don't want to be walking
down the wrong path.' "
Same Object, Different Views
Walking along a path in the Redwall limestone, Mr. Vail splashed water
on fossilized outlines of nautiloids, large aquatic critters that
present one of creationists' chief complaints about standard canyon
Mr. Vail said fossils preserved death without decay, suggesting
catastrophe, and that huge numbers of nautiloids in a six-foot layer
spreading some 5,700 square miles could only be the result of a
Examining a vertical outline of a nautiloid, Mr. Vail ridiculed the
geology explanation, saying it would have had to "stand there like
that for tens of thousands of years while it got buried."
"Anybody want to buy that one?" he added.
A similar question came to the science group from a creationist
student of Professor Saladin who had sent him a long e-mail message to
ponder on his trip. Mr. Gishlick said scientists had not documented
the billions of nautiloids creationists cite and had found no stunning
pattern in their orientation, citing the very vertical fossil Mr. Vail
"These guys don't look like they were buried in something chaotic," he
said. "They look like they floated down to the bottom."
Some around the circle complained about the credence being given to
the creationist argument in order to answer it.
"I don't really care how they reconcile Noah's flood with scientific
things - it's about religion," protested Mary Murray, 54, an artist
from Laguna Beach, Calif., who came with her biology-professor
husband. "We shouldn't be talking about religion at all in the public
Through four days, Mr. Vail mentioned public schools only once, saying
that 80 percent of Christians walked away from their faith when
studying science that confounded the creation story. "It's
foundational to our faith," he said, throwing a stick into the sand in
frustration. "We're raising a generation of confused children, and
it's the public schools that are doing it!"
That morning, Mr. Vail led his troops up a rocky overlook to scout
Hance Rapid before running through its 30-foot drop.
"As you look at the rapid from up here, you can see the run," he
pointed out. "You can see where the rocks are. You can see the bump -
that's obviously somewhere you don't want to go. You can pick your way
through the waves.
"When you're back on the boat, look at the rapid as you're coming into
it and see how much you can see," he continued. "We can read God's
word and we know what we're supposed to do. It's real clear up here
what we're supposed to do."
More information about the paleopsych