[extropy-chat] Elvis Sightings
ben at goertzel.org
Thu Feb 1 19:26:26 UTC 2007
Beaudette's book gives an excellent guide to the scientific
literature on the topic.
For one thing, it can be read as an annotated bibliography of the
published literature on the topic, which is spread across a bunch of
different scientific journals. Starting by reading the papers
recommended in his book is better than reading random papers on cold
fusion found via Googling, for example.
Anyway, if you won't even take the time to read the available
information on the topic, there's not much point in arguing with you
on the topic.
You are ignorant on this topic. I am less so. You are arguing that
I have not convinced you to become informed on the topic.
Fortunately, I have more interesting things to do with my time than
try to convince you to become less ignorant on this topic '-)
I welcome arguments on the reality of cold fusion with anyone who is
familiar with the relevant scientific literature.
On Feb 1, 2007, at 1:29 PM, John K Clark wrote:
> "Benjamin Goertzel" <ben at goertzel.org>
>> I am suggesting you to read a particular book, EXCESS HEAT, which
>> surveys a lot of the scientific journal literature on CF, and also
>> explains the political and social dynamics which led to Nature and
>> Science not wishing to publish papers on CF.
> So let's review, some bozo I've never heard of called Charles G
> wrote a book called "Excess Heat", which I've also never heard of.
> You say
> the book makes the claim that the editors of Nature and Science and
> ALL the
> top physics journals have been full of shit for the last 17 years;
> and then
> you recommend that I read this book. Benjamin, you really don't
> make a very
> compelling case that I should run out right now and buy that book.
> It seems
> a tad more likely to me that Mr. Beaudette is full of shit rather
> than all
> the most respected scientific journals on the planet are.
> John K Clark
> extropy-chat mailing list
> extropy-chat at lists.extropy.org
More information about the extropy-chat