[ExI] Before the Gunfire, Cyberattacks
hkhenson at rogers.com
Wed Aug 13 17:04:33 UTC 2008
August 13, 2008
Before the Gunfire, Cyberattacks
By JOHN MARKOFF
Weeks before bombs started falling on Georgia, a security researcher in
suburban Massachusetts was watching an attack
against the country in cyberspace.
Jose Nazario of Arbor Networks in Lexington noticed a stream of data
directed at Georgian government sites containing the message:
Other Internet experts in the United States said the attacks against
Georgias Internet infrastructure began as early as July 20, with
coordinated barrages of millions of requests known as distributed denial
of service, or D.D.O.S., attacks that overloaded and effectively shut down
Researchers at Shadowserver, a volunteer group that tracks malicious network
activity, reported that the Web site of the Georgian president, Mikheil
Saakashvili, had been rendered inoperable for 24 hours by multiple D.D.O.S.
attacks. They said the command and control server that directed the attack
was based in the United States and had come online several weeks before it
began the assault.
As it turns out, the July attack may have been a dress rehearsal for an
all-out cyberwar once the shooting started between Georgia and Russia.
According to Internet technical experts, it was the first time a known
cyberattack had coincided with a shooting war.
But it will likely not be the last, said Bill Woodcock, the research
director of the Packet Clearing House, a nonprofit organization that tracks
Internet traffic. He said cyberattacks are so inexpensive and easy to mount,
with few fingerprints, they will almost certainly remain a feature of modern
It costs about 4 cents per machine, Mr. Woodcock said. You could fund an
entire cyberwarfare campaign for the cost of replacing a tank tread, so you
would be foolish not to.
Exactly who was behind the cyberattack is not known. The Georgian government
blamed Russia for the attacks, but the Russian government said it was not
involved. In the end, Georgia, with a population of just 4.6 million and a
relative latecomer to the Internet, saw little effect beyond inaccessibility
to many of its government Web sites, which limited the governments ability
to spread its message online and to connect with sympathizers around the
world during the fighting with Russia.
It ranks 74th out of 234 nations in terms of Internet addresses, behind
Nigeria, Bangladesh, Bolivia and El Salvador. Cyberattacks have far less
impact on such a country than they might on a more Internet-dependent
nation, like Israel, Estonia or the United States, where vital services like
transportation, power and banking are tied to the Internet.
In Georgia, media, communications and transportation companies were also
attacked, according to security researchers. Shadowserver saw the attack
against Georgia spread to computers throughout the government after Russian
troops entered the Georgian province of South Ossetia. The National Bank of
Georgias Web site was defaced at one point. Images of 20th-century
dictators as well as an image of Georgias president, Mr. Saakashvili, were
placed on the site. Could this somehow be indirect Russian action? Yes, but
considering Russia is past playing nice and uses real bombs, they could have
attacked more strategic targets or eliminated the infrastructure
kinetically, said Gadi Evron, an Israeli network security expert. The
nature of whats going on isnt clear, he said.
The phrase a wilderness of mirrors usually describes the murky world
surrounding opposing intelligence agencies. It also neatly summarizes the
array of conflicting facts and accusations encompassing the cyberwar now
taking place in tandem with the Russian fighting in Georgia.
In addition to D.D.O.S. attacks that crippled Georgias limited Internet
infrastructure, researchers said there was evidence of redirection of
Internet traffic through Russian telecommunications firms beginning last
weekend. The attacks continued on Tuesday, controlled by software programs
that were located in hosting centers controlled by a Russian
telecommunications firms. A Russian-language Web site, stopgeorgia.ru, also
continued to operate and offer software for download used for D.D.O.S. attacks.
Over the weekend a number of American computer security researchers tracking
malicious programs known as botnets, which were blasting streams of useless
data at Georgian computers, said they saw clear evidence of a shadowy St.
Petersburg-based criminal gang known as the Russian Business Network, or R.B.N.
The attackers are using the same tools and the same attack commands that
have been used by the R.B.N. and in some cases the attacks are being
launched from computers they are known to control, said Don Jackson,
director of threat intelligence for SecureWorks, a computer security firm
based in Atlanta.
He noted that in the run-up to the start of the war over the weekend,
computer researchers had watched as botnets were staged in preparation for
the attack, and then activated shortly before Russian air strikes began on
The evidence on R.B.N. and whether it is controlled by, or coordinating with
the Russian government remains unclear. The group has been linked to online
criminal activities including child pornography, malware, identity theft,
phishing and spam. Other computer researchers said that R.B.N.s role is
ambiguous at best. We are simply seeing the attacks coming from known
hosting services, said Paul Ferguson, an advanced threat researcher at
Trend Micro, an Internet security company based in Cupertino, Calif. A
Russian government spokesman said that it was possible that individuals in
Russia or elsewhere had taken it upon themselves to start the attacks.
I cannot exclude this possibility, Yevgeniy Khorishko, a spokesman for the
Russian Embassy in Washington, said. There are people who dont agree with
something and they try to express themselves. You have people like this in
Jumping to conclusions is premature, said Mr. Evron, who founded the
Israeli Computer Emergency Response Team.
Copyright 2008 The New York Times Company
More information about the extropy-chat