[ExI] Worshiping that Divine Blowhard.

Lee Corbin lcorbin at rawbw.com
Tue Mar 31 04:37:33 UTC 2009


John Clark writes

>>> the fundamentalists can sense the truth, they know that a more 
>>> hideously cruel method
>>> of developing higher life forms can not be imagined.
 >>
>> There you are dead wrong. I can easily imagine a far,
>> far more cruel  world. What if every amoeba, every plant,
>> and every animal had the capacity to suffer as much as we do?
> 
> Well, perhaps they do suffer as much as we do. Who knows?

The theory of evolution tells us so. There would be utterly
*no* point whatsoever for plants to develop feelings since
there is in almost all cases absolutely no action that they
could take based upon those feelings.

> I should amend my remark to say that I cannot imagine any
 > objectively defined scheme to develop complex life forms
> that is more cruel than random mutation and natural selection.

Well, it's hard for me to imagine any alternate objectively
defined scheme to develop complex life forms period!

Lee



More information about the extropy-chat mailing list