[ExI] To Arms!
Fred C. Moulton
moulton at moulton.com
Wed Apr 1 02:52:28 UTC 2009
On Wed, 2009-04-01 at 02:06 +0200, painlord2k at libero.it wrote:
> Il 31/03/2009 8.42, Fred C. Moulton ha scritto:
> > At least one utility is to make sure that anyone who by chance stumbled
> > onto this exchange would realize that your position is not an Extropian
> > position and is in fact extremely non-Extropian. I would not want a
> > reporter on a deadline to be following links or doing some google
> > searches and to read your posts and mistakenly think that the views you
> > have stated about France and Muslim expulsion are in any way
> > representative of Extropian thought.
> I don't know if it is unextropian to let a death cult to flourish inside
> your nation, feeding on your works, and letting it to grow stronger
> until is able to take the power and kill anyone that oppose it.
First to state the obvious; the issue under discussion is the expulsion
of all Muslims from France and to imply that the Muslims in France taken
as an aggregate comprise a death cult is a false implication. Not
trivially false but profoundly false. Islam is not some monolithic
whole. To try to extrapolate from the actions of a few to the larger
group is in this case profoundly false. It has no more validity than to
say that Christians in the USA are a death cult because of the actions
of some in the 1980s and 1990s.
> Paraphrasing a Supreme Justice "Extropy is not a death pact".
Extropy is not an excuse to post obviously false and misleading crap to
the extropy-chat list. This list seems to have the misfortune of having
attracted persons who do not hold Extropian values.
I won't bother with a reply to the rest of your message because you
totally missed the point and I am getting tired of pointing out obvious
What I would say to anyone who seriously advocates that France expel all
Muslims is that they might want to consider consulting professional
psychological help. I am not attempting to diagnose anyone, I do not
know if they are seriously delusional, I do not know if they are simply
making outrageous statements in order to gain attention, I do not know
if they simply enjoy being a pest. Perhaps there is another explanation
for them making such posts. It just might be a reason for concern for
someone to be advocating an action (involuntary deportation of innocent
civilians) which has commonly been considered a Crime against Humanity
since the Nuremberg trials.
More information about the extropy-chat