[ExI] Music
Ben Zaiboc
ben at zaiboc.net
Mon Aug 3 17:20:52 UTC 2020
On 03/08/2020 12:17, John K Clark mentioned:
> .. the near universal appeal of music ...
This is a question that has puzzled me sorely for a long, long time.
Why are we the only animals that seem to have a sense of rhythm? Many
animals make noises of various kinds, sometimes even rhythmic sounds,
but you never see a group of animals getting into a groove the way
humans do.
I've never seen a dog tapping its paw or nodding along to a piece of
music, and even birds that seem to be doing this are oddities (and I
suspect they're not really doing this at all, but just mimicking
humans), and on their own. There's no other species that has a musical
sense, that I know about. The odd thing is, I can't see any advantage
that it confers, and even if it is a spandrel, as John suggests, what
other advantageous trait could it be a result of? I can't think of
anything. So where did it come from? Even other primates don't seem to
have anything approaching it. Are there any documented instances of a
bunch of chimps banging sticks on trees in a coordinated (and
infectious) way, for instance? Anything like that? Even co-ordinated
dancing? I've not heard of any.
Any ideas?
--
Ben Zaiboc
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.extropy.org/pipermail/extropy-chat/attachments/20200803/976b169e/attachment.htm>
More information about the extropy-chat
mailing list