[ExI] Google’s Willow Quantum Chip: Proof of the Multiverse?

[Adrian Tymes]

On Wed, Nov 12, 2025 at 4:41 PM Jason Resch via extropy-chat
<extropy-chat at lists.extropy.org> wrote:
> I only seek to settle the question of whether you think I am alone in raising this particular critique, or if you will acknowledge that this is a common (if not the main) critique that is leveled against superdeterminism.
>
> If you acknowledge that I am not alone in my thinking, then I at least can rest easy with the knowledge that you don't think I was crazy for raising the point I raised (or at least, if I am crazy, that I am in some good company).

I acknowledge that you are not alone in your thinking, and not crazy
for thinking it.  How common your critique is, I am not sure...not for
any flaw in your position, but because it's not the main one I've
heard, and many who voice said main critique seem to think no further,
thus they do not share your reasoning.

Said main critique is, "superdeterminism means there is no such thing
as free will, so none of us are responsible for our actions".  They
repeat this even when I explain how there is potential room for free
will, at least in my version.

I do appreciate that your position is rather more well thought out than that.